Air-quality pablum journalism
“You feel dizzy, everything starts getting like dark, the lights dim, the voices echo all around, you see everything in slow motion. When it’s really bad you can’t breathe, your heart feels like it’s going to pound out of your chest, your fingertips get really cold, you sweat a lot and your nails start getting really purple,” Pasillas remembers. “If you want to feel an asthma attack go under water and try to breathe, your inside burns.” -- Aguilera, CALmatters, January 25, 2019
This subject is interesting to me for two reasons. First, in the Coachella Valley we share in Imperial County air pollution woes. Secondly, because this article is a classic example of public radio baby talk. There's a real story in this piece trying to get out, but it's ruined by "both-side-ism."
First, the patented, trite vig-nette beginning further maimed by reference to some random videogame: Juan Pasillas, the designated Mexican kid with asthma and his family. If the committee of narcissistic twits that wrote this thing had just stuck with the kid and others like him – older and younger – it would have made a compelling piece, because the only air quality monitor that makes sense is the human lung; the rest is mere technology.
But, no. We have to read the experts’ prevarications and even the ludicrous contradictions of a pro-growth politicians, to show we're real, properly trained, ethically disadvantaged American journalists.
My favorite quote that went unchallenged from an expert was that if only they didn’t count the particulate pollution for wind storms, the county would actually achieve annual air-quality attainment. Therefore, the state should exempt those days from the count.
That’s really going to help Mr. Pasillas, his family and his Imperial and Coachella neighbors. All it’s going to do is cover the asses of regulators, which, as public employees, they should not be spending tax dollars to do.
But, if the experts' asses are not adequately covered by this sandy sophistry, BLAME MEXICO. What else?
But this politician, Assemblyman Eduardo Garcia, takes the cake for baloney.
“In the southern parts of California, particularly in my district, there's a tremendous amount of room to grow,” Garcia said. “That's why sustainable environmentally sound policies in our land use development in our transportation systems are extremely important to try to prevent these types of circumstances from continuing.” – Aguilera, CALmatters, 1-25-19
Given Imperial County’s 17-20-percent population of illegal immigrants,1. most of them working in agriculture, this bozo Garcia is the best argument I’ve seen yet for giving illegal immigrants the vote in California.
As an experiment, I’m closing my eyes and guessing before I check that he attended Harvard’s John. F. Kennedy School of Government, which has inflicted upon the state of California more half-educated, morally blunted, arrogant technocrats than any institution in the land. Chico State does a better job and without the attitude.
Now, the check. He did! He did!2.
As for the social justice activists of Comite Civico del Valle, they got grants to put up air-quality monitors. But today they are called CCV. Inc, they have an office on Main Street in Brawley, and they are an umbrella organization doling out grants to lesser groups of activists.
I suggest to the worthy activists in the Imperial and Coachella valleys that they step back from fund-raising for just a second and consider the proposition that air-monitoring technology, like much other technology, dulls consciousness rather than raising it. Evidence in support of the proposition regarding air quality can be found all over California and beyond.
– Badlands Journal editorial board
Living in one of the most polluted places in California
Elizabeth Aguilera | CALmatters |
Living in one of the most polluted places in California | 89.3 KPCC
Juan Pasillas is trying to be stealthy. Roving around a quiet city, wearing a mask, looking around corners while on the lookout for mutants, changed by an airborne infection.
Pasillas’ avatar in the video game “Last of Us” moves quickly, wary of any movement. It could be someone whose brain has been taken over by the fungus and whose body is mutating.
The Imperial County teenager finds some irony in his game choice. Stuck indoors whenever he is not at school or at work, Pasillas, 18, actively avoids the polluted air in his community that caused asthma attacks so bad they sent him to the hospital several times as a kid.
The Pasillas family lives in the county with some of the worst air quality in the state.
Imperial County does not meet federal air quality standards, and state officials are working on plans to begin to decrease pollution. Only two other places in California have the same distinction, the San Joaquin Valley and the South Coast Air Basin, which includes most of Los Angeles County.
The rural border county is overburdened by agricultural burning, the nearby drying Salton Sea, emissions from factories in its border neighbor Mexicali. It’s so bad children in the county are hospitalized and visit the emergency room more often for asthma than anywhere else in California.
This is not quite anyone’s vision of the California dream, popularly imagined as variations based on building a safe, secure and successful life. Many people arrived in Imperial County to mine their version of the dream - through farming or factory work, in a rural, affordable area, that is also close to family or friends in the U.S. and just over the border in Mexico.
Instead, Imperial is emblematic of life for millions of people around the state who live under an umbrella of bad air quality or who have contaminated soil or lack access to clean water. The majority of these environmental hot spots in California are concentrated in low-income communities of color and there is often little attention paid to improving the situation, said David Pettit, senior attorney for the National Resources Defense Council.
“Everybody wants the same thing for their kids, a good education, a healthy place to live and clean air and water,” said Pettit. “For a lot of people it’s difficult to figure out how to do that. Families should not have to worry that if their kids go outside and play baseball or soccer because they might get sick.”
Imperial got an F in high ozone and particle pollution from the American Lung Association. The city of El Centro, the county seat, is ranked seventh worst city among 187 areas for particle pollution across the country, according to the lung association’s report.
These tiny invaders can embed in the lungs, enter the bloodstream and are known to cause asthma and other respiratory illnesses including lung cancer.
Residents regularly deal with a brown haze that causes eyes to burn as smoke climbs into the air from factories and agricultural burning. In addition, toxic dust from the shrinking Salton Sea, which has been used for farm runoff for decades, permeates the air. Gasoline vapors rise from millions of idling cars and diesel trucks at the border each year. Across the border more than 180 maquiladoras, or manufacturing facilities, contribute to the bad air quality.
Officials had done little to address the worsening air quality over the years but things are changing on that front, spurred by the work of Luis Olmedo and the social justice organization he runs Comite Civico del Valle, which works on health and air issues.
In 2013, Comite Civico set up 40 air monitors around the region to capture real-time data about air quality levels through a partnership with the University of Washington and the California Environmental Health Tracking Program, a collaboration between the Public Health Institute of Oakland and the state Department of Public Health. The project was funded by a $2 million grant from the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences. Now the network, IVAN Air Monitoring, or Identifying Violations Affecting Neighborhoods, monitors continue to register air quality in the region from the Salton Sea to across the border in Mexicali.
Olmedo said the organization wanted to measure air quality in the areas where people actually live and not just rely on the few government monitors that are in the area. The state only had six monitors in the county before the IVAN network.
“We are giving the public a resource, we communicate the data in real time, so people can register and get alerts whenever the levels are high,” Olmedo said.
Air quality in Imperial County has been so bad that it has been labeled a nonattainment area under the federal Clean Air Act in 2014, said Michael Benjamin, chief of air quality planning and science division for the California Air Resources Board. That means it does not meet the standards set under the law.
“We’re very cognizant of the fact that the residents of Imperial County are breathing unhealthy levels of air pollution. So we have a very robust set of actions to try to work with the agencies on both sides of the border as well as community groups to address and mitigate those sources of pollution,” said Benjamin.
The agency adopted a plan last spring as framework for decreasing air pollution in the area over the next decade. It’s also working with Mexico to decrease pollution from its factories and unpaved roads as well as considering more regular smog check requirements and stricter rules for agricultural burning.
But for now residents cope with the dangers by signing up for ozone and air alerts, keeping their children indoors and minimizing their use of fireplaces or other contributors to bad air quality.
The Imperial Valley has one of California’s highest rates of childhood asthma hospitalization and emergency room visits, double that of the state, according to the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development. In Imperial County – the prevalence of asthma is 15.1 percent, higher than the state average, according to state Public Health Department data. It is also one of the state’s poorest counties.
Pasillas is one of those stats. He went to the hospital several times throughout middle and high school after suffering terrible asthma attacks. It usually happened after he was outside during physical education class.
“You feel dizzy, everything starts getting like dark, the lights dim, the voices echo all around, you see everything in slow motion. When it’s really bad you can’t breathe, your heart feels like it’s going to pound out of your chest, your fingertips get really cold, you sweat a lot and your nails start getting really purple,” Pasillas remembers. “If you want to feel an asthma attack go under water and try to breathe, your inside burns.”
Back then a doctor told Pasillas’ parents that the best thing for him would be for the family to move away, said Monica Pasillas, his mother.
“We thought, do we go to San Diego, but it’s very expensive there,” said Monica Pasillas, whose husband delivers furniture for a local retailer. “It wouldn’t work, we couldn’t make ends meet.”
Pettit called the suggestion “wildly unrealistic.”
“For people working for a living and struggling to make ends meet, they are not going anywhere,” he said. “People don’t get that, especially if you are coming from a place of white economic privilege, it’s unrealistic, it’s not the way most of California works.”
Assemblyman Eduardo Garcia, the Imperial Valley Democrat, said the answer is in a fix, not for everyone to leave.
“In the southern parts of California, particularly in my district, there's a tremendous amount of room to grow,” Garcia said. “That's why sustainable environmentally sound policies in our land use development in our transportation systems are extremely important to try to prevent these types of circumstances from continuing.”
Comite’s monitors, many of them at schools, have already shown increased air pollution and found higher levels of small particulate levels than was previously known. Now the information is being used to create strategies to decrease the pollution through efforts at the state level and with Mexico.
Those efforts and work by Garcia, like new laws he sponsored to address air quality and include communities in the process, have spurred actions by the state air board to set goals for the region, sometime in the 2030s, and invest resources in trying to improve the situation.
“It's frustrating sometimes that it takes a while to get things up and going,” Garcia said. But “it’'s certainly very refreshing and gives us a tremendous amount of hope that we're moving in the right direction.”
In December, the California Air Resources Board approved a plan that would allow the state to exempt extremely high wind days from counting toward PM10 goals. That would mean about 15 days a year when poor air quality from windstorms would not be factored into meeting air quality goals.
In the fall the board launched the Community Air Protection Program to help improve air quality in some of the most impacted areas of the state, including part of Imperial County.
“We found that Imperial County would attain the 2.5 standard if it were not for the contribution of emissions from Mexico,” said Benjamin from the air board. “Imperial County is more challenging because of Mexico and the impact from Mexico and our limited authority and the nature of the desert environment.”
Despite the hurdles California and Mexico have been working together as best they can. Mexicali is putting up 50 air monitors, borrowed from the state, and has already taken action to ban fireworks and pave roads.
For Monica Pasillas and her family, who live in a double-wide home across from agricultural fields, the improvements can’t come soon enough.
Her daughter Maritza, 26, also suffers, for her its pollution-induced migraines.
“Whenever I have a migraine I have to stop doing what I’m doing,” she said. “That’s what backs me up in, sometimes, school or anything I’m doing. It stops my routine completely.”
Even Monica Pasillas has lasting scars. She lost her left eye to a bacterial infection last year after a day in the garden. Doctors told her they did not know what caused and blamed the contaminated air.
So she continues to worry about her children and how impacted they might be by the environment.
“You think about a rosy future for your children, that nothing is going to happen to them,” she said. “We spent nearly three years with Juan going to the doctors when he should have been playing outside. He couldn’t do that. He didn’t have a normal childhood.”
The California Dream series is a statewide media collaboration of CALmatters, KPBS, KPCC, KQED and Capital Public Radio with support from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting and the James Irvine Foundation.
Public Policy Institute of California
2020 Census: Counting Imperial County
Tess Thorman, Vicki Hsieh, Sarah Bohn
(2) Assemblyman Eduardo Garcia, 56th District, Biography