The ban was opposed by vineyard operators.
“It seems like we’re being targeted for vines, whereas other things that might actually lead to more significant drought reduction are not even being mentioned in this -- agriculture, housing, horses,” said Malibu resident Dan Fredman, who has been operating a vineyard for about five years. “All of those things use significantly more water than grapes do. -Paige Austen, Patch.com, June 17, 2015
Clearly the Santa Monica vigneron does not regard his form of conspicuous consumption as agriculture.
Seulement en Ste, Monique, Didi! (If Samuel Beckett had been a Californian.)
We wonder if the LA Board of Supervisors' decision was motivated by any concern for natural resources beyond the personal viewscapes of some prominent citizens and hobbies of some landowners of the few remaining acres of wildlands left in that thirst region.
All over Northern California we see vineyards climbing up the sides of canyons and mountains, wherever the weather sort of permits. The only thing one can really surmise from the sight of these precipitous plantations has nothing to do with the possible quality of wine they might produce, but only that we can be certain the owner doesn't do his own tractor work.
Here in the San Joaquin Valley, we see huge vineyards in addition to the almond orchards that also have destroyed precious natural habitat, particularly clearly in the crowding of west side wildlife preserves in Merced County. And the almonds are devouring seasonal pastureland on the east side, which is a valuable habitat for endangered species as well as feed for the county's beef industry. But our supervisors hate natural resources of any kind and can see no purpose for them but to rip, disk, roll and plant them. And the only cattle they like dairy cows. -- blj
County Bans New Vineyards Amid Drought Concerns
The county has instituted a temporary ban on new or expanded vineyards on a swath of the Santa Monica Mountains.\
PAIGE AUSTIN (Patch Staff)
Spurred primarily by concerns about water use amid the extended drought, the county Board of Supervisors has imposed a temporary ban on new or expanded vineyards on a large swath of the northern Santa Monica Mountains.
The ban affects the 32-square-mile Santa Monica Mountains North Area, which includes unincorporated land west of the city of Los Angeles and reaching the Ventura County line, adjacent to Calabasas, Agoura Hills and Westlake Village.
“Quite recently, 12 new vineyards have been approved just in this area,” Supervisor Sheila Kuehl said. “And if you take a longer look at it, 25 new vineyards have been approved. Sixteen more applications are pending for vineyards.”
She stressed that the ban is only a temporary step designed to give county planners a chance to review water issues as they relate to vineyards and determine if additional conditions should be imposed on future projects.
“No, vineyards did not cause the drought,” Kuehl said. “I didn’t cause the drought either by using too much water, but the point is the aggregate of everybody’s actions is contributing.”
Richard Bruckner, the county’s director of Regional Planning, said people who want to install a vineyard simply bring an application to the county that is approved administratively.
Imposing a temporary ban will “give us a chance to think of a more thoughtful approach to maybe, perhaps, some conditions for the vineyards, perhaps look at the water certainly look at the water quality coming off of the vineyards,” he said. “So it would be an opportunity to look at perhaps some conditions that may be applicable to vineyards in the future.”
The ban was opposed by vineyard operators.
“It seems like we’re being targeted for vines, whereas other things that might actually lead to more significant drought reduction are not even being mentioned in this -- agriculture, housing, horses,” said Malibu resident Dan Fredman, who has been operating a vineyard for about five years. “All of those things use significantly more water than grapes do.
“... I realize it’s difficult to get much sympathy for people who live in Malibu,” he said. “This morning we’ve been hearing about valley fever, living-wage issues, all of that, but the reality is most of the people who are working with farming, we’re out there doing it ourselves.”
Greg Barnett of Malibu Coast Wines, added that he has “enjoyed the Santa Monica Mountains my whole life, and then I’ve welcomed the whole wine country that is just blossoming behind our backyard in the mountains.”
“I just can’t believe that this is going to put a ban on all future vineyards as well as any sort of vineyard expansion, which is kind of distressing to our family,” he said.
Beyond the amount of water used by vineyards, Kuehl said the county also wants to look at their water runoff, which can contain chemicals from pesticides and fertilizers.
The board is expected to revisit the issue during a public hearing on July 28.